All Blogs
Category

CGT Alternative Proposal: What It Means for Property Investors

The capital gains tax changes due on 1 July 2027 may not go through as planned. An alternative proposal from independent MP Allegra Spender has gained attention, and the Greens, who hold the balance of power in the Senate, have said they are open to considering it. This blog explains where the debate stands and what each proposal would mean for property investors. Nothing is set in stone, and CGT only applies if you sell, so the best response is to keep making sound decisions and avoid reacting to a proposal.

Written by
Ravi Sharma
Published on
November 20, 2026

A Quick Recap: How CGT Works Now

Capital gains tax applies when you sell an asset for more than it cost. If you hold it in your own name for more than 12 months, you receive a 50% discount on the gain.

For example, if you buy a property for $500,000 and sell it for $600,000, the gain is $100,000. With the discount, $50,000 is added to your taxable income for that year, which can push you into a higher tax bracket. Companies and trusts are taxed under different rules.

Your own home is generally exempt under the main residence exemption, and none of the proposals discussed here change that.

‍

What the Budget Changes Would Do

The federal budget announced that from 1 July 2027, the 50% discount is replaced with indexation and a 30% minimum tax on real gains. Indexation adjusts the cost of an asset for inflation, so you are taxed on the gain above inflation instead of the whole gain.

The changes apply to property, shares, and business interests. Under a transitional rule, growth accrued before 1 July 2027 is still taxed under the existing discount. Our blog to the CGT changes explains how the split works.

Depending on the size of the gain, inflation, and how long you hold, indexation can produce a higher or lower tax bill than a 50% discount.

‍

The Alternative Proposal

According to reports, independent MP Allegra Spender put forward an alternative in October. It would introduce a 40% CGT discount for active assets, such as business interests, instead of the inflation-based approach. It would keep the inflation-adjusted approach for passive assets such as property.

As reported, that means the alternative would not change the proposed treatment of property. The difference is for businesses and other active investments.

Who has said what:

  • Allegra Spender proposed the 40% discount, arguing for a tax system that rewards risk-taking and treats businesses simply.
  • The Greens, whose Treasury spokesperson Nick McKim called the idea “very interesting”, have said they are willing to consider it. The Greens hold the balance of power in the Senate.
  • The Treasurer, Jim Chalmers, has not backed the alternative, and has said the inflation-based approach is easier to understand.
  • The Coalition has said it opposes the budget’s CGT changes.
  • Business and investor groups have raised concerns about the budget plan, including its effect on competitiveness.

‍

Why Timing Matters

The government wants its remaining budget bills, including the CGT changes, through the Senate quickly to avoid delays running into next year. Since the Greens’ support is needed, any negotiation over the alternative could slow the process.

If the bills do not pass in time, the start date could move beyond 1 July 2027, or the details could change. The next federal election is due in 2028, so the political context may also shift. None of this is certain, and the outcome depends on negotiations that are still under way.

‍

What It Could Mean for Property Investors

The proposal does not change the property treatment, as reported. Property stays on the indexation model under both the budget plan and the alternative. The main uncertainty for property investors is whether the 1 July 2027 start holds and whether other details change.

The transitional split date matters. Under the budget plan, growth before 1 July 2027 keeps the 50% discount. If the start date moves, the split date could move with it, so check the final legislation before relying on it.

CGT only applies when you sell. If you are not planning to sell soon, nothing is triggered. Many investors hold for many years, and gains are only assessed at a sale.

Ownership structure affects the outcome. A company does not receive the 50% discount under the current rules, and trusts have their own changes, including a 30% minimum tax on distributions under the budget, with a draft fix still pending. Our investment property tax blog covers the basics, and it is worth settling the structure with an accountant before you buy.

Tax is one part of a decision. This 2026 budget changes breakdown covers how negative gearing changed too. A tax rule should not be the only reason to buy or sell.

‍

What We Do Not Know Yet

  • Whether the Senate passes the budget bills as drafted
  • Whether the alternative gains enough support to change the legislation
  • Whether the 1 July 2027 start date holds
  • How “active” and “passive” assets would be defined if a split is introduced
  • Whether any further changes follow

‍

What to Do Now

These are general steps, not advice.

  1. Do not buy or sell because of a proposal. The rules may change before they take effect.
  2. Keep your cost base records. The contract, settlement statement, and records of improvements and costs matter under any version.
  3. Model your position under each scenario. Ask your accountant to compare the current rules, the budget plan, and the alternative for any property you may sell.
  4. Settle structure before you buy. Changing it afterwards can trigger stamp duty and capital gains tax.
  5. Watch the outcome. The final legislation will set the details, including the start date and the transitional rule.

‍

Ready to Plan Around the Tax Changes?

At Search Property, we help Australians cut through the noise and build data-driven investment strategies aligned with long-term wealth goals. Our buyers agents have helped thousands of clients build wealth through property because we focus on fundamentals, not headlines.

Book a FREE Investment Assessment Call with Search Property.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the alternative CGT proposal?

According to reports, independent MP Allegra Spender proposed a 40% CGT discount for active assets such as business interests, instead of the inflation-based approach in the budget. It would keep the inflation-adjusted approach for passive assets like property.

Would the alternative change CGT for property?

As reported, no. Property would stay on the indexation model proposed in the budget. The difference is for businesses and other active investments.

Will CGT change on 1 July 2027?

That is the planned start date, but the legislation has to pass the Senate first, and the Greens’ position gives the alternative a role in the negotiations. A delay or changes are possible.

Do I pay CGT if I do not sell?

No. CGT is assessed when a CGT event occurs, such as selling the property. Holding it does not trigger a bill.

What happens to CGT if I inherit a property?

Australia has no inheritance tax, and a person’s death does not generally trigger CGT, which usually arises when the person who inherits the property sells it. The tax depends on factors such as the original cost base, when the asset was bought, and the final 2027 rules, so it's worth speaking to an accountant.

Should I sell before the changes?

That depends on your situation. A sale triggers costs and tax now, and the final rules are not yet settled. It is important not to panic sell. Selling only to avoid a tax change can cost more than the change itself, and you give up future rent and growth. Model the scenarios before making a decision.
Disclaimer: Important Notice for Readers

‍
By reading the content provided on this blog, you acknowledge and agree to the terms outlined in this disclaimer, binding yourself to its provisions unconditionally.

This blog presents information for informational, educational, and general non-advisory purposes only. It's important for you, the reader, to understand that the information provided does not take into account your specific personal, financial, or other circumstances. Consequently, we do not offer legal, financial, investment, or taxation advice, recommendations, or guidance. Before acting upon any information from this blog, you are strongly advised to consult with an independent professional, including legal, financial, taxation, accounting, or other relevant advisors, to verify the information’s relevance to your particular situation.

The information is provided in good faith, derived from sources believed to be reliable. However, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information to your individual circumstances, needs, objectives, or financial situation. The information may be selective and has not been independently verified. Therefore, it should not be the sole basis for any decision-making.

We expressly disclaim any liability for errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the information, as well as any direct or indirect losses, damages, or expenses that arise from relying on our content, regardless of the cause, including negligence or other factors. Your engagement with this blog is entirely at your own risk.

Please be aware, we do not hold an Australian Financial Services Licence as defined by section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), nor are we authorised to provide financial services, and we have not provided financial services to you.
A drawing of a house on a black background.

It’s not too late to start

Contact us to start building today.