All Blogs
Category

The Truth About the 5 Percent Deposit Scheme and Why It Can Hurt First Home Buyers

Two major banks have shifted their forecasts toward interest rate hikes in 2026, pushing consumer confidence down and creating uncertainty for buyers. But while most people hesitate, strategic investors understand how inflation, tight supply, and changing sentiment can create strong buying conditions. Here is how to position yourself over the next six months.

Written by
Ravi Sharma
Published on
January 7, 2026

The 5 percent deposit scheme has been marketed as an easier path into the housing market, but the reality is far more complex. Recent stories from buyers who used the scheme and now face financial distress have reignited debate about whether this policy genuinely helps Australians or simply pushes them into riskier debt.

You need to understand how this scheme works, where people are going wrong, and what lessons you can take from the experiences of buyers who rushed in without proper due diligence.

What the 5 Percent Deposit Scheme Actually Does

The scheme allows you to purchase a property with only a 5 percent deposit. The government steps in and guarantees the other 15 percent, which means:

On paper, this sounds like an ideal shortcut for first home buyers. But without the right asset, the right structure, and the right advice, you can easily end up in financial trouble.

That is exactly what happened to a couple who purchased an apartment in early 2024 with a 5 percent deposit. They saved $40,000, bought in Sydney, and believed they were following all the right steps. What followed highlights the hidden risks many buyers overlook.

Where Things Went Wrong

Shortly after settling, the couple discovered major waterproofing issues that caused their strata fees to jump from $1,500 to $2,500 per quarter. On top of that:

  • The neighborhood was noisy.
  • The community was unfriendly.
  • Their children felt unsafe.
  • They eventually moved out and rented a different home.

This is a common pattern. Many buyers assume they must own the place they live in, even if the numbers do not make sense. You do not need to live where you buy. You can rent where you want and invest where the fundamentals are strong.

Because they bought the wrong asset in the wrong area, they ended up becoming accidental investors. Once they moved out, the property was no longer a suitable home and also not a suitable investment. Their agent then asked them to drop rent by $150 per week below market because nobody wanted the property.

They now face a choice between breaking even and being locked out of the rising Sydney market, or holding on and risking bankruptcy.

This is not a property problem. It is buying the wrong property problem.

Why the Scheme Can Be Dangerous for Unprepared Buyers

Borrowing 95 percent of a property’s value gives you very little margin for error. If you pick the wrong asset:

  • Minor issues become major financial problems.
  • High strata costs destroy your cash flow.
  • Weak locations lead to vacancies.
  • Any downturn leaves you exposed.
  • You have no buffer because you contributed almost nothing upfront.

The scheme magnifies both outcomes. A great purchase can grow quickly because you are leveraged. A bad purchase becomes a disaster just as fast.

This is why many people who use the scheme end up in trouble. It is not the scheme itself. It is the lack of due diligence, the lack of investment logic, and the lack of expert support.

Why Most Failed Purchases Follow the Same Pattern

Many Australians buy their first home for the wrong reasons. You look at the kitchen. You look at the bathrooms. You focus on lifestyle first and numbers second. Then when you outgrow the home, you turn it into an investment property without ever checking whether it actually performs like one.

This is how accidental investors end up stuck for years. You have:

  • A property that does not grow.
  • A yield that does not support the loan.
  • Vacancy issues that drain your cash flow.
  • Ongoing costs you did not anticipate.

At the same time, quality properties elsewhere in the country continue rising in value. If you had purchased in the right areas with strong fundamentals, you could be up $100,000 to $150,000 in the same two-year period.

There is a massive difference between buying a home and buying an investment property. Without guidance, the odds of getting it wrong are high.

Personal Accountability Matters

One of the clearest lessons from this situation is the role of personal responsibility. Many people rush into buying because of pressure from family, friends, politicians, or social expectations.

But the people pressuring you often:

  • Do not invest themselves.
  • Do not have a portfolio.
  • Do not understand the numbers.
  • Do not know the risks.

You must be very careful about who you listen to. It is better to get advice from people who have a proven track record and a data driven approach than from people who simply repeat what they were told decades ago.

The Real Issue Is Not the Scheme. It Is the Execution.

The 5 percent deposit scheme is not the villain. The problem is buying the wrong type of property through the scheme.

If you select a poor performing asset, the scheme accelerates your losses.
If you select a strong, growing, high demand asset, the scheme accelerates your gains.

This is why some buyers build wealth quickly while others get trapped. The difference is due diligence, location selection, data analysis, and expert guidance.

Key Lessons You Should Take From This

If you are considering buying with a small deposit, learn from this situation and avoid the same mistakes:

  • Choose assets with strong fundamentals.
  • Check strata, building reports, and local market data.
  • Prioritise capital growth and rental demand.
  • Never buy based on emotion or pressure.
  • Rent where you want and invest where the numbers make sense.
  • Get expert support before you purchase.

Buying property is easy. Buying the right property is difficult. That is why so many people get stuck after their first purchase and never build a meaningful portfolio.

If you want to avoid the mistakes countless buyers make and you want a clear pathway to choosing the right investment property, you do not have to do this alone.

Book a free discovery call with Search Property and get expert guidance before you make your next move.

Disclaimer: Important Notice for Readers

By reading the content provided on this blog, you acknowledge and agree to the terms outlined in this disclaimer, binding yourself to its provisions unconditionally.

This blog presents information for informational, educational, and general non-advisory purposes only. It's important for you, the reader, to understand that the information provided does not take into account your specific personal, financial, or other circumstances. Consequently, we do not offer legal, financial, investment, or taxation advice, recommendations, or guidance. Before acting upon any information from this blog, you are strongly advised to consult with an independent professional, including legal, financial, taxation, accounting, or other relevant advisors, to verify the information’s relevance to your particular situation.

The information is provided in good faith, derived from sources believed to be reliable. However, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information to your individual circumstances, needs, objectives, or financial situation. The information may be selective and has not been independently verified. Therefore, it should not be the sole basis for any decision-making.

We expressly disclaim any liability for errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the information, as well as any direct or indirect losses, damages, or expenses that arise from relying on our content, regardless of the cause, including negligence or other factors. Your engagement with this blog is entirely at your own risk.

Please be aware, we do not hold an Australian Financial Services Licence as defined by section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), nor are we authorised to provide financial services, and we have not provided financial services to you.
A drawing of a house on a black background.

It’s not too late to start

Contact us to start building today.